League of Legends: Not a DotA “remake” but nonetheless a terrific (freeware) game

Wow. It has been a dang long time since I have posted on dotTech. That is not to say I spent my time off wisely – played League of Legends until my brain turned into mush – but I sort of miss this feeling. So what better “come back” post to make then to talk about the one thing I have wasted my past 2-3 weeks on. (Oh, and thank you to everyone that sent me messages while I was gone and welcomed be back!)

I am not sure how many dotTechies are gamers, but for those that are I am sure most of you have heard of DotA (Defense of the Ancients). For those that don’t know, let me explain. Blizzard Entertainment is a video game developer that is known for their famous RTS (real-time strategy) – and most recently – MMORPG (massive multiplayer online role playing game) games. Starcraft, one of Blizzard’s classics, is one such RTS that was released in 1998.

Blizzard, in their wisdom, built a “custom map maker” in Starcraft allowing users to create their own “custom maps” (or “scenarios” or “games” or whatever you want to call them) to play using the Starcraft engine. One such “custom map” built for Starcraft by users is “Aeon of Strife”, a predecessor of DotA. Now, flash forward  to 2005 when Icefrog starts developing DotA for Warcraft III (Blizzard’s most recent RTS game) and DotA, literally, becomes a one-hit wonder. Thousands of people from around the world play the game; so much so that international tournaments are held just for DotA. The only problem is, DotA is limited by the Warcraft III engine and mechanics since, essentially, it is just a “custom map” for Warcraft III. So being such a popular game, many other developers have popped up and starting creating DotA “remakes”, or in other words, whole new standalone games that are based on DotA but not limited to the Warcraft III engine (you don’t need to buy Warcraft III to play these “remakes”). League of Legends (LoL) is one such “remake” (although as I will explain later, I feel LoL is different enough from DotA to be called its own game and not a clone).

Like DotA, in LoL there are two teams (currently each team can be comprised of 5 people each but there are plans of making 3v3 maps also) that fight against each other – the blue and purple teams. The fundamental goal of each team is to try to destroy the other team’s “nexus”. Whoever destroys the other team’s nexus first wins. Each team is comprised of “champions” (individual characters controlled by actual players), “creeps” (computer controlled monsters champions need to kill to get experience – to level up – and gold), and buildings (such as towers, “inhibitors”, etc.). Before the game starts, players are allowed to select their champions, “spells” (two “extra” spells to use in game), “mastery” (a focus which helps make your champion stronger), and “runes” (special “boosters” that help you in game). Once the game starts, the two teams battle it out trying to destroy the other team (the higher level you are the stronger you are, and the better items you have – you use the gold to purchase items – the stronger you are). Here is a ~5 minute video showing some in-game action:

Currently there are 43 champions users can select from in LoL, with the newest champion – Poppy – arriving just this last Wednesday:

However, don’t expect to be able to use all 43 champions right as you start playing. You see, LoL is a freeware game; anyone can download it for free, and play it for free. However, the developer (Riot Games) still needs to make money, right? So, Riot developed LoL on a micro-transaction model (MTS). What this means is LoL has an in-game “store”:

From this store users can buy champions, skins, runes, and “boosts”. To buy anything, users need to use LoL “currency”. There are two types of LoL “currency”:

  • Influence Points (IP) – IP are points you get after you finish playing a game. If you win, you get more IPs. If you lose, you get less IPs. How many IP points you get depends on how long the game was that you just finished. For an average 35-40 minute game, except to get 150-200 IP if you win, and 70-100 IP if you lose. IP are completely free and how many you have totally depends on how actively you play LoL.
  • Riot Points (RP) – RP are points you purchase with real money (USD).You can buy game cards at a local store, or you can purchase them online:

Champions can be bought with either IP or RP points…

…but runes can only be bought with IP and skins and “boosts” can be bought only with RP. The cool thing about this MTS system is everything that affects in-game play, you need not use real money to purchase it – you can use IP (which you get for free by playing the game) to get it. So even if you don’t have deep pockets, you can still own hardcore in LoL – I do (sometimes =P).

Now don’t worry. Even if you are new, you will still be able to play with champions. Every week Riot makes 10 champions available for free; anyone can use them regardless of if you bought them or not. So, one week 10 champions are available for free, and the next week a different 10 champions are available for free; the rotation continues on like that. You can, of course, at any time purchase a champion and use him/her whenever you want.

In terms of game play, I must say I am fairly impressed with how well balanced the game is. Sure some may disagree with me, but generally speaking no one champion with “overpowered”; how well you do in a game depends on your skill level and how well you play. Of course, there are exceptions. For example, Twitch was grossly overpowered and got a well deserved nerf in the most recent patch (may still need a few more nerfs). Also, the newest hero, Poppy, is  fairly overpowered dishing out a ton of damage and taking hits like a truck (Poppy is already scheduled for a nerf because she does “more damage than intended”).

What I also like about LoL is that it is a team game front to back, left and right. Sure there are “carries” on each team in each game, but without proper teamwork, no team will ever win. This mechanic of teamwork contrasts greatly with that of DotA. In DotA yes teamwork was required, but usually one person – who got farmed or fed – could run through the enemy team and win the game single-handedly. In LoL even if one of your teammates – or you yourself – are fed or farmed, it is critical to do ganks and fight as a team, or you may as well kiss that win goodbye and surrender when 25 minutes pass (in LoL teams have the option to surrender after 25 minutes of gameplay).

Other noteworthy/DotA-differentiating features of LoL:

  • The game isn’t over until the fat nexus explodes. Unlike DotA where if a game is one sided it will tend to stay one sided until the game ends, in LoL the pendulum swings both ways. In LoL even if your team is getting dominated the whole game, one single battle that you win – either by fluke, luck, or darn good strategy – can turn the tide and result in your team’s victory. You see once a champion is level 15+, it takes a good 40-60 seconds for the champion to revive after he or she has died. If your once-losing team kills all enemy champions, you have 40-60 seconds to rip through your enemies base and kill their nexus. In DotA, a tide-turner like such is easily avoided by simply “buying back” your hero once he/she dies. However, LoL does not have any sort of “buy back” concept (although there are ways to resurrect instantly such as the “revive” summoner’s spell but they are just specs compared to the “buy back’ concept). So, if the whole team dies late game, it gives the opponents an opportunity to end by the game by rushing to the nexus.
  • Epic ganks thanks to the brush. Throughout the maps in LoL, there are areas where users can “hide” their champions called “brush”. If a champion is standing in the brush, no one from outside the brush can see the champion but the champion can see them. So, jumping the enemy with the element of surprise is often done. Have your whole team stand in the brush and wait for the enemy to pass by can be exhilarating. Of course, LoL newbies will find the brush annoying – I did – but once you get used to it, the brush is an integral and unique part of LoL gameplay.
  • The ability for inhibitors to respawn. In DotA and LoL before you can kill the throne/nexus, you must kill the progressing towers and buildings. In DotA once you kill the buildings where creeps spawn (“barracks”), the buildings are gone for good. In LoL, the buildings (called inhibitors) respawn after a period of time. So don’t fret if you lose an inhibitor and don’t be overjoyed if you kill an inhibitor. An inhibitor gone will just come back sooner rather than later.
  • The ability to reconnect to the game if you disconnect. In DotA if you disconnect from a game, you can no longer reconnect to the game and rejoin the battle. In LoL, however, if you disconnect from a game, you simply need to run LoL and login to reconnect to the same game. This, of course, has a downside. Once you start a game in LoL, you cannot play a different game (on the same account) until that first game is finished.

As I inferred to earlier and just explained, although they may seem like minor changes, all the differences between DotA and LoL really make them two different games. Yes, while they may look similar on paper, when you play both games, you will notice an inherent difference between the two; they just feel and play different. That doesn’t mean LoL is a bad game; on the contrary it is a terrific game. However, that means, in my opinion, calling LoL a DotA “remake” is more of a marketing strategy than a reality.

Now there are two aspects of LoL which I feel that can be improved upon:

  • The inability to “deny” your own buildings or creeps. A critical aspect of DotA – which often differentiated the noobs from the pros – is the ability to “deny” your own creep or building. When you “deny” a creep or building, you simply kill it yourself with it is low health. This way, you deny your opponent experience and/or gold. In LoL, Riot Games decided to not implement this denying feature. Their main reasoning for not including the ability to deny is “it increases the early game imbalance between ranged and melee champions” and it “leads to passive gameplay”. Both reasons, in my opinion, are weak.
    • First of all, the “early game imbalance” between ranged and melee champions is an essential part of the decision you make when you pick a ranged or melee champions. Both types of champions – ranged or melee – have their own pros and cons and you pick the one you want. Anyone that has played DotA knows denying creep kills (and/or buildings) is not about having a ranged or melee hero but rather about timing and precision. Plus, assuming there is a large “imbalance” between ranged and melee champions when it comes to denying, wouldn’t the same imbalance exist when it comes to killing enemy creeps?
    • Denying creeps and/or buildings does not lead to passive gameplay at all. It adds a whole new dimension to gameplay and actually results in more activity by users trying to not only get their own creep kills and champions kills, but also trying to deny the opponent creep kills so they have less experience and gold.

I do hope Riot considers adding in the ability to deny creeps and buildings in the future.

  • The ability to “rent” champions and runes. Lets face it: spending your IP and/or RP on a champion or rune is a grueling decision. Sometimes you may just want to play that champion or use that rune for a limited amount of time or games, or just to try them out. Allowing people to “rent” champions and runes would be helpful for people who don’t want to keep the champion or rune permanently.

Also, although Riot Games is continually improving the games – fixing bugs, adding new features, etc. – currently League of Legends is a little bit buggy. Before the most recent patch often times the graphics rendering in game would be very laggy and “choppy” when I would in large battles. The problem was not at my end – my computer can handle LoL just fine and my internet connection is one of the best – but rather in the game engine. Other minor bugs include disappearing/messed up icons (especially when you relog), messed up matchmaking (I once played a game with a person who claimed to queue with his friends but ended up in my game), etc. However, as I said Riot is continually improving the game. Since the last patch, the performance improved considerably and the lag mostly disappeared and I am sure the other bugs will be quickly ironed out.

All in all, I highly recommend League of Legends to any gamer, or anyone that wants to give it a try. You can get started with LoL by visiting the following links:

System Requirements

  • 2 GHz processor
  • 1 GB RAM
  • 750 MB available hard disk space
  • Shader version 2.0 capable video card
  • DirectX 9.0 capable video card
  • Windows XP SP2, Windows Vista SP1, or Windows 7 (Mac OS is currently not supported)

Version Reviewed

v1.03.11

Click here to get started with League of Legends

Share this post

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

24 comments

  1. guiiller

    DoTa was the original, HoN copied it from dota and LoL did the same thing..no matter how hard i try i can’t give respect to HoN and LoL, their making money out of other’s ideas. dota was not even profiting from its? maps and icefrog updated them without asking anything in return.

  2. guiiller

    DoTa was the original, HoN copied it from dota and LoL did the same thing..no matter how hard i try i can’t give respect to HoN and LoL, their making money out of other’s ideas. dota was not even profiting from its? maps and icefrog updated them without asking anything in return.

  3. Steve Jaqvaar

    I just started playing LoL a couple of days ago. You know how we always hate sequels and copycats? How the original is always best? How we like Don McLean’s “American Pie” but not Madonnas, Indiana Jones #1 but not the sequels, and how “they don’t make cars like they used to anymore”?

    Well, this is not the case with LoL. DotA was an original idea with a lot of good things about it. It was a good-old fun game with simple rules but complicated strategy. And I loved it. But LoL is so much better. Despite the nostalgia, I’m trying to find some reason not to play it, something bad to say about it, something they left out or simply overlooked. And I can’t. LoL is EVERYTHING that DotA was, yet so much better. Not your average eye-candy improvements, either. They’ve kept every single element that made DotA great, corrected all the faults and added some cool little details (like the summoner spells, which are fairly easy to use even for a beginner and add to the strategy and fun).

    Overall, this is just as classic as the original, and has really taken the original idea a step further. LoL is to DotA what the glider is to a paper plane.

  4. Jacob

    First this:

    @Adrian: Yeah, you can confuse someone alot when you talk about LoL with your friend (with someone around). Try it, it’s fun.

    @Jbob: LoL doesn’t have lots of same abilities and heroes, HoN does. HoN is pretty much DotA with a better engine. LoL isn’t.

    Also, the reason LoL plays different (from DotA) is that HP (health points) and MP (mana points)  aren’t as important as in DotA. In Dota, you lose most of your HP and then you have to go to your base, come back again, and by the time you get back your laning partner is one level above you (which isn’t always a bad thing).  The same thing applies to MP.

    I’m not a persistent viewer/user of dottech, i just ended up here when searching for a solution to a bug (i think it’s a bug, at least).

  5. Paf

    Hi Ashraf, I like games, so it’s a good surprise to see a game review here. Thanks a lot. Please post more games reviews whenever you feel like it. There is more life besides the tech reviews. Have fun, my friend.

  6. Ashraf
    Author/Mr. Boss

    @dude: Really? I guess since I don’t use RP I never realized runes can only be bought with IP. Thanks it is fixed.

    Also, no where did I say or insinuate Icefrog created DotA. I don’t know where your “500,000” number comes from but Icefrog is the one credited with making DotA what it is today. Yes DotA existed before his time – I even played it and can vouch for how incomplete, inbalanced, and not-so-fun it was – but without Icefrog today’s DotA wouldn’t be today’s DotA. Nonetheless, though, I was just giving a quick summary.

  7. dude

    Just a correction. You can’t buy runes with RP. The whole
    idea is that you can only earn runes by playing. Also you make it sound like icefrog created Dora. He improved it but there where already 500,000 people playing it before he came along.

  8. future hacker

    I’m a gamer… too bad I’m an OFF-LINE gamer. I have a slow Internet connection…I’m lebanese by the way (fast Internet, yeah right)
    It would be great Ashraf if you reviewed freeware games like in freewaregenius.com (I’m not doing any publicity by the way), DotTech would attract more people, especially gamers.

  9. Adrian

    Oh Sh**! I don’t have a 2 GHz processor! Which is such a waste since this game sounds great! I was addicted DotA a few years ago, but dropped it when I got hooked on to the PES series. Anyways, welcome back Ashraf.

    Also, a joke: The game’s name is LoL? (for Laughing out Loud :))

  10. gmon

    Hi! I just today downloaded a trial of City of Heroes, and now I read this, I think everyone wants to just have fun lately.. I may try this one also, not sure about having to buy upgrades though. But at least it’s free. But what is a nerf? And how are the controls in this game? Mouse, keyboard, hard, easy..

  11. Kraal FictionWriter

    @Locutus: Thank you for the link. =)

    I did find out during installation that they give you the ToS and EULA to accept. Again.

    I played a game. And lost. It was a practice game against NPC’s…=/

    And then I went and made another game to play, again only NPC’s, and realized it was too late to start another one.

    My thoughts on the game? It’s pretty good. I like whole concept of it, even if it was difficult for my first game. I liked my quirky little guy, Corki or however it was spelled. I thought he was funny.

    I like how they give you only four spells, and you don’t have to choose from a bunch, because that wouldn’t work in such a fast paced game. I enjoyed the challenge, and will work more on getting better morrow.

    I kept forgetting to visit the shop and buy items, and in the end only had 2 of them that helped me. So that was kinda meh. I didn’t make good use of the recall spell either. Although…most of the time I was dying with seconds anyway. I had trouble running away. And trouble with NOT rushing into combat when all my minis are dying or behind me.

    I haven’t got too much to say on the game, as I only played one time so far. But I recommend you atleast give it a try, if you’re willing to play games that last anywhere from half an hour to a couple hours depending on skill of the players. (I’ve only played with bots. =P I’m glad that’s an option though. It saves me the embarrassment! XD )

  12. Ron

    Hmmm…

    It’s really too bad I’m not a gamer. I just finished putting together a Win7 machine with a Powercolor HD 3650 video card and 6Gb of RAM. Still, it might be fun to take a break from 123 Solitaire!

    Thanks for the head’s up.

  13. Locutus

    @Kraal FictionWriter: I tried, but this is the best I could come up with:

    [Removed by Ashraf. Reason: Wholy crap that is a lot of scrolling. Just follow the link below.]

    They removed the page, though, but Google cached it.
    http://74.125.155.132/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fleagueoflegends.com%2Flegal%2Fterms_of_use&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a

    @Ashraf: because these were removed, I’d try making a DIV element in the article with a fixed height and width that scrolls containing this.

  14. Kraal FictionWriter

    I’m going to try the game. I can’t find the EULA or the ToS, though…and I’d like to read them…

    If you know where they are, I’d be grateful for the heads up.

    I’ll make another post on my thoughts of the game after playing for a bit.

    And, of course, welcome back. =)