[Windows] Best free file manager program — Q-Dir vs Xplorer2 Lite vs Explorer++ vs FreeCommander vs Multi Commander
January 27, 2013 109
Email article | Print article 
Windows Explorer is the default file manager provided with Windows. It is fine for most people but is not ideal in many aspects such as moving files around. This is where freeware file managers come in; with options such as multiple panes, these programs make managing your files a breeze! On that note, here are the best free file managers available for Windows.
This review is part of our Best Free Windows Software section. Check out more articles on the best free Windows programs from here.
Table of Contents
- Best Free File Manager
- Runner Up
- Honorable Mention 1
- Honorable Mention 2
- Honorable Mention 3
- Other Alternatives
Best Free File Manager
Program Name: Q-Dir
Developer: Nenad Hrg
Download Size: 455KB
Version Reviewed: 5.47
Requires: Windows NT/98/Me/2000/XP/2003/Vista/Server 2008/7
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 7.96MB
Pros
- Portable
- Supports up to 4 panes
- Has tabs
- Supports drag + drop
- Supports filters
- Supports different views
- Has a magnifier (magnifies any portion of the screen)
- Ability to add favorites
- Has a preview pane (in addition to the 4 panes) for previewing files/folders
- Has all the normal file management functions that are found in Windows Explorer
Cons
- Too many panes can become quite cumbersome
Discussion
Q-Dir is both simple and effective and is a very capable file manager solution.
One of the best aspects of Q-Dir is its user interface. This may come across as strange but the program offers users several options for adjusting the layout to their preferences. Users can choose to do the following:
- Display the default 4 square panes arrangement
- Display a 3 pane arrangement with only one horizontal window at the top
- Display a 3 pane arrangement with only one horizontal window at the bottom
- Display 2 vertical panes
- Display 2 horizontal panes
- Display 4 vertical panes
- Display 4 horizontal panes
- Display 3 vertical panes
- Display 1 vertical pane in the left pane and 2 horizontal panes in the right pane
- Display 2 horizontal panes in the left pane and 1 vertical pane in the right pane
- Display a single pane
In addition to panes, tabs are supported.
There isn’t really a best display option; the option anyone chooses depends on their preferences and how many files or folders they will be manipulating at any instant. Q-Dir also gives users options for the type of icons they want to display such as tiles and small icons. It also includes the option of using a color filter in order to differentiate between different types of items. Also handy is the zoom tool which allows for any area of the screen to be magnified. Users can also choose to duplicate the window and choose and select any one of several themes which are available.
Another brilliant characteristic of the program is the ability to save the current state. This allows users to resume browsing at a later period of time, after closing the manager, as if the program was never closed in the first place. Users can implement built-in windows functions from directly within the program such as:
- Shutting down
- Opening the run prompt
- Opening the command prompt
There is also an option for restarting the manager which may be necessary to allow certain changes made to files or the program itself. In addition, provision is made to include files from network locations. Q-Dir can also be set as the default explorer and thus can essentially completely replace all of the functionality of Windows Explorer. Users also have the option of previewing their audio, image and video files before opening them. Finally users can add frequently accessed locations to their favorites so as to have quick and easy access to them.
The only issue I have found with this program is that when using multiple pane configurations, the program can become quite cluttered especially when using 3 or 4 panes. But then again, more than two panes is the attraction of Q-Dir.
Q-Dir is an excellent program which should comprehensively address all of the basic to advanced needs of anyone using the program.
Runner Up
Program Name: Xplorer2 Lite
Developer: ZABKAT
Download Size: 1.77MB
Version Reviewed: 2.2.0.2
Requires: Windows
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 3.24MB
Discussion
Xplorer2 Lite is a complete file manager solution which bests Windows Explorer in many aspects.
Firstly Xplorer2 Lite makes use of a dual window system where 2 separate folders are displayed in one window thus allowing for the easy transfer of files. Additionally the program makes use of tabs. These two features alone make Xplorer2 Lite a very powerful contender. Also there are various options for how the icons are displayed. These are:
- Large icons
- Small icons
- List
- Details
- Thumbnails
Bookmarks allow for the fast access of user favorites and can be added quite easily. Another interesting feature is the sticky selection feature which is similar to holding ctrl and selecting items. Xplorer2 Lite also makes use of a built in text viewer/editor and allows for the previewing of .txt files as well as audio, video and image files.
Perhaps the most powerful feature of Xplorer2 Lite is its DOS command functionality. Users can use this provision in order to create scripts to process batch files. Xplorer2 Lite also allows users to clone their current windows and manage the corresponding files. The program also allows users to save the state of their browsing just before closing the program which allows for its reopening in exactly the same state as it was in before.
My two main issues with Xplorer2 Lite are the lack of a powerful built in search function and, the annoying prompts which appear if a feature which is not included in the LITE version is unknowingly selected by users of the program.
Despite these 2 gripes, it is clear to see that Xplorer2 Lite is both an effective program, capable of some quite advanced functionality such as the DOS command feature.
Honorable Mention 1
Program Name: Explorer++
Developer: David Ecreg
Download Size: 578KB
Version Reviewed: 1.3.4.485
Requires: Windows 2000/XP/Vista/7
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 13.54MB
Discussion
Explorer++ is a lightweight but effective file manager.
The GUI of Explorer++ is similar to that of Q-Dir when the single division option is selected along with the ‘one-4-all’ option under extras tree view. In other words, Explore++ only has one pane but it does use tabs. It’s interface is very well laid out. Explorer++ offers users options such as bookmarking and a command prompt option and the ability to customize the colors of the program.
One of the assets of this program is the ease with which it allows users to copy file, folder and universal file paths. Users simply need to select the file/folder and select the required action under the file menu. Also the options for ‘removing’ files from folders go beyond what one would typically expect. Users can choose to:
- Delete (moves to the recycle bin)
- Delete permanently (skips the recycle bin but the file may be recoverable via a data recovery program)
- Destroy File(s) (the file in question will not be recoverable)
Explorer ++ also allows users to use the wildcard select function. This function is used to help persons search for files whose names they are not sure of; users simply need to type the portion of the file name that they do know, followed by an asterisk which represents the missing character(s). Under the ‘Go’ menu shortcuts to popular locations such as ‘Computer’, ‘My Documents’, ‘My Music’, ‘My Pictures’, ‘Desktop’ and ‘Recycle Bin’ among others can be found and accessed.
There are 2 issues I have found with Explorer ++. Firstly, the interface is not as customizable as that of Xplorer2 Lite or Q-Dir and users are limited to a single window system. In addition there is no preview pane available.
However, Explorer ++’s lightweight nature combined with its ease of use and great features still make it one of the better file managers out there today.
Honorable Mention 2
Program Name: FreeCommander
Developer: Marekk Jasinski
Download Size: 2.54MB
Version Reviewed: 2.8.2
Requires: Windows 2000/XP/Vista/7
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 11.64MB
Discussion
The additional functionality offered by FreeCommander over Windows Explorer is a sure way to improve your file browsing experience.
Like Xplorer2 Lite, Free commander uses a dual pane window system with tabs which allows for ease of navigation and file transfer between folders. Users are given several choices as to how they would like to display their icons such as:
- List
- Details
- Small Icons
- Large Icons
- Thumbnails
- Display split/dual windows in a stacked manner or side by side.
Unlike Xplorer2 Lite however, FreeCommander does include its own powerful search functionality, allowing users to track down files with ease. The program also has powerful filtering capabilities.
FreeCommander has the unique functionality of being able to pack and unpack files which would come in quite handy as no additional programs need to be opened in order to carry out these functions. Also, FreeCommander gives users the ability to create and verify MD5 Checksums. It also gives provision for several time saving shortcuts and allows users to set their favorite tools which are programs of the users’ choice. Additionally users can save frequently accessed or important locations using the ‘favorites’ option. FreeCommander also allows users to take desktop snapshots if desired.
Perhaps one of the stronger points of FreeCommander is the way it integrates some of the elements of Windows directly into the program. For example, the command prompt, control panel, start menu, desktop and a few select system directories can be accessed via icons located on the toolbar of the program. Clicking on these icons opens up drop down menus and allows for the selection of the desired folders/options.
The main issue I have with this program is the lack of the preview option. According to some dotTechies, it is possible to download TotalCommander plugins and use them with FreeCommander; one of those plugins adds the preview option. I haven’t tried it myself, though.
FreeCommander is definitely worth trying out as a Windows Explorer substitute since it possesses some great features which Explorer simply does not offer.
Honorable Mention 3
Program Name: Multi Commander
Developer: Mathias Svensson
Download Size: 5.ooMB
Version Reviewed: 2.8.1
Requires: Windows
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 9.06MB
Discussion
Multi Commander is another powerful option for all of your file manager needs.
On opening the program users are prompted to choose how they want the interface to look and given the following options:
- Commander Style “Look ‘n’ Feel”
- Windows Explorer Compatibility “Look ‘n’ Feel”
- Option to choose from multiple profiles
Like Xplorer2 Lite and FreeCommander, Multi Commander uses a dual window system with tabs. It also takes full advantage of tabbed browsing which is an invaluable feature in the world of file managers. Users are also given the option of customizing the interface of the program to their preferences.
Similarly to FreeCommander, this program also allows users to pack and unpack files. In addition it allows for the testing of the integrity of these packed files. It also has ftp support. In addition users will have access to tools for the simpler tasks involved in photo manipulation such as the rotation and conversion of picture formats. It can also display media information for movies as well as view the properties of audio files. Multi Commander also allows for the renaming of multiple files at once which could come in quite handy. It can also convert text to different formats such as the format for Unix. The search function must not be forgotten as this is extremely important for locating files. In combination with the advanced filter options present, users can easily find their files.
One of my main issues with this program are the buttons at the bottom of the program window make the window very cluttered and are simply not laid out very well. Also, there is no preview option.
Other Alternatives
- PowerDesk
- BetterExplorer
- Ultra Explorer
- Unreal Commander
- … and many more
About the author: William View all posts by William
Related »
![[Windows] Replace system or restricted files without reboot with ‘SysMate- System File Walker’](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/06/SysMate-UI-134x90.png)
![[Windows] Securely hide or encode text through digital steganography with Text to Color](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/06/Text-to-Color-UI-134x90.png)
![Microsoft uses Siri to bash the iPad, again [Video]](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/06/microsoftad-134x90.jpg)
![[Windows] Reg is an alternative registry editor that has more features than regular RegEdit](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/06/Reg-user-interface-134x90.png)
109 Comments »
Leave A Response »
@Rob (Down Under):
“Yes.
Delete the file called Startup.ini and run the program. It will create a new Data folder, in the folder that you are in.”
Magic! Worked treat. Many thanks.
@Rob (Down Under): Xplorer² has dual panes AND tabs.
@Rob (Down Under): Ha ha! What about those dual-pane lovers who love tabs in their panes! Can I vote again for FreeCommander (which is free, and XYP isn’t)?
@BGM:
I disagree, FreeCommander is the second best, the best one for me is FreeCommander XE! ;)
Top 3:
1. FreeCommander XE
2. Explorer++
3. Q-Dir
Thank you everyone for the suggestions! We should have the review on best free Windows file manager up soon.
After the mini-debate within these very comments about dual panes vs. tabs, I find it surprising that the reviewer does not even acknowledge tabs as a differentiator. He fails to mention which of the candidates have this feature or not.
This review may be useful for those who never use tabs, but not at all for those of us who do. It would be better entitled “Best free multipaned file manager program”.
I use Q-Dir and it has tabs, dont know about the others.
@Bub:
Thanks Bub,
I thought I had slipped into a parallel universe where no one used or cared about Tabs, leaving me as a lone voice.
Thanks everyone for your suggestions. William has posted the review. Enjoy!
I, too, love Free Commander – dual panes, tabs, etc. What more could you want? I’ve tried all the others mentioned here, and more, (in addition to the XYPlorer freebie offered recently), and keep coming back to Free Commander.
I don’t understand the comment about no previews. I can get a quick view of virtually all my files (although I had to download some Total Commander plugins). That’s another huge advantage to Free Commander – the availability of all the add-ons developed for Total Commander.
@eric506:
If I can take the liberty of expanding Bub’s comment (thoughts) -
It would be helpful, if those of us writing in to recommend a program, would indicate whether they are using it ‘in panes’ or ‘in tabs’
That is, in which of those capacities/capabilities are you recommending it
I am sure many of us appreciate and react to members recommendations, and those belonging to either the ‘pane’ tribe or the ‘Tab’ tribe, will know which recommendations to check out.
Lets acknowledge that everyone has their own favorite for their own personal reasons. For me its Xplorer², which I have used for years and am quite happy with. My main reason is its customization options, which allow me to tailor it to my personal tastes.
I’ve looked at several of the others mentioned here (plus a few others) and none offer as much customization as Xplorer². My opinion, my personal choice.
@BearPup:
|I got’s to know (Dirty Harry Bank robber on the footpath after Harry has emptied his revolver)
Do you use Panes ?
(That is not a minor preference as you are implying, it would be a crucial factor in choosing a File Manager)
@Rob (Down Under): Actually, I don’t use panes…for me, they aren’t a big deal. It is a personal preference.
@JackS:
I had portable version 4-444 of Q-Dir, which I have now updated to the latest version. As I recall it took a lot of tweaking to get rid of the panes, and get it the way God intended. Luckily I found an easy way to ‘transfer’ all my tweaking to that new version. I have written to the author, suggesting that he includes an easy way to un -pane it.
. . .
What you might be interested in, is I have worked out how to tweak the colors for individual File Types. EG Say you wish .txt files to be a different color (lighter blue, than the other blue ones).
Yell out if anyone is interested.
You can write me direct if you like, so that we do not clutter up this web page with tweaks, etc for just one program.
robhp AT iprimus DOT com DOT au
Rob
PS I am liking Q-Dir (Tab tribe)
‘Clover’ might also come in handy. It’s not a replacement file manager, but an extention that adds multi-tabs to Windows Explorer. You can also add folder bookmarks. Works on XP and later 32bit/64bit Windows versions and is good enough for me.
http://ejie.me/clover-wings-for-explorer
I own a PC repair business, so a File Manager is something I use to the max. For many years PowerDesk was my choice. It offered every possible feature I required, but every version proved to be buggy. Fast forward to October, 2012 and I’ve switched to Windows 8. Due to cost savings moves and terrible reviews for the newest version of PowerDesk, it was time to search for a freeware alternative. My criteria: multi-pane, highly customizable, compatible with Windows 8, loaded with features. For my use, I eliminated anything not compatible with 8, any application not being actively developed and any application that differed from PowerDesk (I like panes, not tabs). I was left with: Multi Commander, xplorer2 and Free Commander. xplorer2 ultimately would require payment, so when it didn’t stand out it was eliminated. Free Commander (the new version) seems perfect, but it’s in beta so I have to eliminate it (FOR NOW). Multi Commander has won out. As the reviewer stated here, the buttons make it cluttered so I customized the app by removing them. Multi Commander is stable and serves my every need with the exception of a file viewer for PDFs. Free Commander has such a viewer, but I don’t use software in beta. To be continued….
@Rob (Down Under):
Rob, you do to seem to like to make hard work for yourself with your “tweaking” and “transferring” of Q-Dir.
Until this thread started I was extremely happy with FreeCommander XE and XYplorer, but I last Monday I downloaded Q-Dir portable (version 5.47). “Un-paning” it is as simple as clicking on the appropriate icon on the menu bar (RHS).
Colours for individual file types can be set by clicking on “Extras”, then “…more options” and then “Colors”. Various document suffixes are included, but not “.txt”
Q-Dir seems to be a great find as under “…more options” it is highly configurable.
I think you mentioned that you don’t like “panes”, I find that most file managers allow single pane viewing if you have a look hard enough. Personally, I frequently use both tabs and panes, but when extra panes get in the way, I switch to single pane.
BTW, a link for Q-Dir 5.47, (portable or installer), (32 or 64 bit) is:
http://www.softwareok.com/?Download=Q-Dir
@Jim Carter:
I do understand that you need tools that you can depend on but FreeCommander has been in beta for a long time now and has always been perfectly stable. So I don’t think its “beta” status should affect you.
@jayesstee:
When I tweaked version 4-444 it was not just a one click exercise. EG getting Tree on left, and details on right, and getting it to not throw ones hard work out of the window when it closed/restarted. (what fool does not want such programs to re-open they same way as when you closed it. Would you believe some browsers discard your hard work)
Perhaps he got flamed enough that he made it easier ?
I notice that he has adopted some common functionality, that he did not have in 4-444. EG Ctrl N for a new sub folder
. . .
Regarding coloring one file type (eg .txt) are you saying that cannot be done ? (I have done it)
@Jim Carter:
Don’t let the beta status prevent you from trying FreeCommander XE. It’s not beta in the sense of “be careful, this might ruin your data” — but rather “the developer is still adding and testing features before the official release.” Some new feature might not work entirely as expected. Well, no problem; everything else works great. And users can test it and give feedback to improve a later version. You can get an idea of what the issues are by browsing through the Beta Bug Reports section of the FC forum. I don’t think there are any deal-killers there.
Despite replies #30 and 54 which explicitly distinguished FreeCommander XE from the older FreeCommander, I find it remarkable that the reviewer makes no mention of the former. If he had tried FC-XE, he would have found that it indeed does have previews — the lack of which he objected to in plain FC.
FC-XE is in active development with frequent releases, while FC stopped development in 2009. I’d like to see a review comparing the most up-to-date versions of the candidates.
@Bub: I agree with you, Bub. Even if the reviewer may not value tabs for himself, it’s remarkable in light of their frequency in these comments that he doesn’t even mention them.
Dual panes have certain benefits, and tabs have other benefits. For example, dual panes make it easy to visually compare two folders at once, and to easily copy or move files between folders. Tabs make it easy to switch between or return to favorite folders. A user might have a single pane with multiple tabs, or dual panes with no tabs, or dual panes plus multiple tabs depending on personal work style and what needs to be done.
I used to be quite satisfied with a paid version of Servant Salamander because it offered dual panes. But after I discovered the value of tabs (in dual panes) with FreeCommander, tabs became one of my top criteria when evaluating file manager programs. As you pointed out, Bub, this review offers no help on that front. I’m not saying the reviewer should value tabs as highly as I do. But they should be recognized as a significant feature of the genre, and at least mentioned in the features for each program.
@Rob (Down Under): Re: colours, I said:
“Colours for individual file types can be set by clicking on “Extras”, then “…more options” and then “Colors”. Various document suffixes are included, but not “.txt””
To save you looking, here is the list of file types that can be cloured:
*.zip; *.rar; *.gz; *.7z; *.mp”; *.avi; “.wma; #DIR *.jpg; *. jpeg; *. Png;
*. git; *. bmp; “. ico; *. Html; *. htm ; *.url; *. pi; *. cgi; *. php; *. pdt;
*. doc; *. rtf; *.cpp; *.hpp; *.h; *.exe; *.dll; *.bat
Enjoy!