[Windows] Best free file manager program — Q-Dir vs Xplorer2 Lite vs Explorer++ vs FreeCommander vs Multi Commander
January 27, 2013 93
Email article | Print article 
Windows Explorer is the default file manager provided with Windows. It is fine for most people but is not ideal in many aspects such as moving files around. This is where freeware file managers come in; with options such as multiple panes, these programs make managing your files a breeze! On that note, here are the best free file managers available for Windows.
This review is part of our Best Free Windows Software section. Check out more articles on the best free Windows programs from here.
Table of Contents
- Best Free File Manager
- Runner Up
- Honorable Mention 1
- Honorable Mention 2
- Honorable Mention 3
- Other Alternatives
Best Free File Manager
Program Name: Q-Dir
Developer: Nenad Hrg
Download Size: 455KB
Version Reviewed: 5.47
Requires: Windows NT/98/Me/2000/XP/2003/Vista/Server 2008/7
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 7.96MB
Pros
- Portable
- Supports up to 4 panes
- Has tabs
- Supports drag + drop
- Supports filters
- Supports different views
- Has a magnifier (magnifies any portion of the screen)
- Ability to add favorites
- Has a preview pane (in addition to the 4 panes) for previewing files/folders
- Has all the normal file management functions that are found in Windows Explorer
Cons
- Too many panes can become quite cumbersome
Discussion
Q-Dir is both simple and effective and is a very capable file manager solution.
One of the best aspects of Q-Dir is its user interface. This may come across as strange but the program offers users several options for adjusting the layout to their preferences. Users can choose to do the following:
- Display the default 4 square panes arrangement
- Display a 3 pane arrangement with only one horizontal window at the top
- Display a 3 pane arrangement with only one horizontal window at the bottom
- Display 2 vertical panes
- Display 2 horizontal panes
- Display 4 vertical panes
- Display 4 horizontal panes
- Display 3 vertical panes
- Display 1 vertical pane in the left pane and 2 horizontal panes in the right pane
- Display 2 horizontal panes in the left pane and 1 vertical pane in the right pane
- Display a single pane
In addition to panes, tabs are supported.
There isn’t really a best display option; the option anyone chooses depends on their preferences and how many files or folders they will be manipulating at any instant. Q-Dir also gives users options for the type of icons they want to display such as tiles and small icons. It also includes the option of using a color filter in order to differentiate between different types of items. Also handy is the zoom tool which allows for any area of the screen to be magnified. Users can also choose to duplicate the window and choose and select any one of several themes which are available.
Another brilliant characteristic of the program is the ability to save the current state. This allows users to resume browsing at a later period of time, after closing the manager, as if the program was never closed in the first place. Users can implement built-in windows functions from directly within the program such as:
- Shutting down
- Opening the run prompt
- Opening the command prompt
There is also an option for restarting the manager which may be necessary to allow certain changes made to files or the program itself. In addition, provision is made to include files from network locations. Q-Dir can also be set as the default explorer and thus can essentially completely replace all of the functionality of Windows Explorer. Users also have the option of previewing their audio, image and video files before opening them. Finally users can add frequently accessed locations to their favorites so as to have quick and easy access to them.
The only issue I have found with this program is that when using multiple pane configurations, the program can become quite cluttered especially when using 3 or 4 panes. But then again, more than two panes is the attraction of Q-Dir.
Q-Dir is an excellent program which should comprehensively address all of the basic to advanced needs of anyone using the program.
Runner Up
Program Name: Xplorer2 Lite
Developer: ZABKAT
Download Size: 1.77MB
Version Reviewed: 2.2.0.2
Requires: Windows
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 3.24MB
Discussion
Xplorer2 Lite is a complete file manager solution which bests Windows Explorer in many aspects.
Firstly Xplorer2 Lite makes use of a dual window system where 2 separate folders are displayed in one window thus allowing for the easy transfer of files. Additionally the program makes use of tabs. These two features alone make Xplorer2 Lite a very powerful contender. Also there are various options for how the icons are displayed. These are:
- Large icons
- Small icons
- List
- Details
- Thumbnails
Bookmarks allow for the fast access of user favorites and can be added quite easily. Another interesting feature is the sticky selection feature which is similar to holding ctrl and selecting items. Xplorer2 Lite also makes use of a built in text viewer/editor and allows for the previewing of .txt files as well as audio, video and image files.
Perhaps the most powerful feature of Xplorer2 Lite is its DOS command functionality. Users can use this provision in order to create scripts to process batch files. Xplorer2 Lite also allows users to clone their current windows and manage the corresponding files. The program also allows users to save the state of their browsing just before closing the program which allows for its reopening in exactly the same state as it was in before.
My two main issues with Xplorer2 Lite are the lack of a powerful built in search function and, the annoying prompts which appear if a feature which is not included in the LITE version is unknowingly selected by users of the program.
Despite these 2 gripes, it is clear to see that Xplorer2 Lite is both an effective program, capable of some quite advanced functionality such as the DOS command feature.
Honorable Mention 1
Program Name: Explorer++
Developer: David Ecreg
Download Size: 578KB
Version Reviewed: 1.3.4.485
Requires: Windows 2000/XP/Vista/7
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 13.54MB
Discussion
Explorer++ is a lightweight but effective file manager.
The GUI of Explorer++ is similar to that of Q-Dir when the single division option is selected along with the ‘one-4-all’ option under extras tree view. In other words, Explore++ only has one pane but it does use tabs. It’s interface is very well laid out. Explorer++ offers users options such as bookmarking and a command prompt option and the ability to customize the colors of the program.
One of the assets of this program is the ease with which it allows users to copy file, folder and universal file paths. Users simply need to select the file/folder and select the required action under the file menu. Also the options for ‘removing’ files from folders go beyond what one would typically expect. Users can choose to:
- Delete (moves to the recycle bin)
- Delete permanently (skips the recycle bin but the file may be recoverable via a data recovery program)
- Destroy File(s) (the file in question will not be recoverable)
Explorer ++ also allows users to use the wildcard select function. This function is used to help persons search for files whose names they are not sure of; users simply need to type the portion of the file name that they do know, followed by an asterisk which represents the missing character(s). Under the ‘Go’ menu shortcuts to popular locations such as ‘Computer’, ‘My Documents’, ‘My Music’, ‘My Pictures’, ‘Desktop’ and ‘Recycle Bin’ among others can be found and accessed.
There are 2 issues I have found with Explorer ++. Firstly, the interface is not as customizable as that of Xplorer2 Lite or Q-Dir and users are limited to a single window system. In addition there is no preview pane available.
However, Explorer ++’s lightweight nature combined with its ease of use and great features still make it one of the better file managers out there today.
Honorable Mention 2
Program Name: FreeCommander
Developer: Marekk Jasinski
Download Size: 2.54MB
Version Reviewed: 2.8.2
Requires: Windows 2000/XP/Vista/7
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 11.64MB
Discussion
The additional functionality offered by FreeCommander over Windows Explorer is a sure way to improve your file browsing experience.
Like Xplorer2 Lite, Free commander uses a dual pane window system with tabs which allows for ease of navigation and file transfer between folders. Users are given several choices as to how they would like to display their icons such as:
- List
- Details
- Small Icons
- Large Icons
- Thumbnails
- Display split/dual windows in a stacked manner or side by side.
Unlike Xplorer2 Lite however, FreeCommander does include its own powerful search functionality, allowing users to track down files with ease. The program also has powerful filtering capabilities.
FreeCommander has the unique functionality of being able to pack and unpack files which would come in quite handy as no additional programs need to be opened in order to carry out these functions. Also, FreeCommander gives users the ability to create and verify MD5 Checksums. It also gives provision for several time saving shortcuts and allows users to set their favorite tools which are programs of the users’ choice. Additionally users can save frequently accessed or important locations using the ‘favorites’ option. FreeCommander also allows users to take desktop snapshots if desired.
Perhaps one of the stronger points of FreeCommander is the way it integrates some of the elements of Windows directly into the program. For example, the command prompt, control panel, start menu, desktop and a few select system directories can be accessed via icons located on the toolbar of the program. Clicking on these icons opens up drop down menus and allows for the selection of the desired folders/options.
The main issue I have with this program is the lack of the preview option. According to some dotTechies, it is possible to download TotalCommander plugins and use them with FreeCommander; one of those plugins adds the preview option. I haven’t tried it myself, though.
FreeCommander is definitely worth trying out as a Windows Explorer substitute since it possesses some great features which Explorer simply does not offer.
Honorable Mention 3
Program Name: Multi Commander
Developer: Mathias Svensson
Download Size: 5.ooMB
Version Reviewed: 2.8.1
Requires: Windows
Approximate Memory Usage When Idle: 9.06MB
Discussion
Multi Commander is another powerful option for all of your file manager needs.
On opening the program users are prompted to choose how they want the interface to look and given the following options:
- Commander Style “Look ‘n’ Feel”
- Windows Explorer Compatibility “Look ‘n’ Feel”
- Option to choose from multiple profiles
Like Xplorer2 Lite and FreeCommander, Multi Commander uses a dual window system with tabs. It also takes full advantage of tabbed browsing which is an invaluable feature in the world of file managers. Users are also given the option of customizing the interface of the program to their preferences.
Similarly to FreeCommander, this program also allows users to pack and unpack files. In addition it allows for the testing of the integrity of these packed files. It also has ftp support. In addition users will have access to tools for the simpler tasks involved in photo manipulation such as the rotation and conversion of picture formats. It can also display media information for movies as well as view the properties of audio files. Multi Commander also allows for the renaming of multiple files at once which could come in quite handy. It can also convert text to different formats such as the format for Unix. The search function must not be forgotten as this is extremely important for locating files. In combination with the advanced filter options present, users can easily find their files.
One of my main issues with this program are the buttons at the bottom of the program window make the window very cluttered and are simply not laid out very well. Also, there is no preview option.
Other Alternatives
- PowerDesk
- BetterExplorer
- Ultra Explorer
- Unreal Commander
- … and many more
![[Windows] Minimize and lock open windows to prevent unauthorized access with WinLock](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/05/WinLock-UI-134x90.png)
![How to bring back the classic drop-down menu in Office 2007, 2010, and 2013 on Windows [Tip]](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/05/ubit-134x90.jpg)
![Another Windows 8 fail [Image]](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/05/windows_8_fail_another-134x90.jpg)
![This computer is “never obsolete” [Image]](http://cdn.dottech.org/media/2013/05/emachine_never_obsolete-134x90.png)
@Rob (Down Under): Or even: “. . . that can be coloured”
Hurry back editing facility!
@Scott Youngman: We didn’t add FreeCommander XE to the list simply because it is still in beta. It may be a stable beta, but it is still beta. When it comes out, obviously it will replace FreeCommander.
@Bub: @Scott Youngman: You are right, we didn’t focus on tabs as a differentiator between products because they all support tabs! And, to be fair, we did mention explicitly tab support for Xplorer Lite but did not for the other four. I’ve updated the review to reflect that all five programs we mention have support for tabs.
Thanks for your feedback!
I wish you would revise this page to reflect the proper name of the ZABKAT program: Xplorer2 Lite. In the article headline, and in the section headline for the program, you use Xplore2 Lite–dropping the “r.” If you run a search on the page, you might turn up other uses of the wrong name as well.
@Jeff: Whoops, sorry about that. Fixed.
#fail
In your rating of FreeCommander, you say, “The main issue I have with this program is the lack of the preview option.”
Now, I don’t understand that. FreeCommander can, (if you use the settings correctly) preview just about anything, and on top of that, you can even use TotalCommander’s lister plugins, which lets you preview even vector files and psd files. In IMHO, I don’t think the Surveyor spent enough time trying out the programs.
Also, FC has a lot of color options, too, and can do anything XPlorer2 can do, except maybe it doesn’t have as many commandline options.
But I think something that was NOT mentioned, that should have been mentioned, was the feature whereby FC allows for the creation of an indefinite amount of customizable command buttons, which can perform any kind of commandline functionality. Q-Dir is very limited in this respect. Plus, FC has an awesome set of toolbars – which the others lack (only TotalCommander has any comparison there).
@BGM: Thank you. Updated article to reflect the TC plugins aspect.
@Everyone: Please do realize, it just isn’t possible for us to talk about and discuss every detail in programs; there is just too much things going on to discuss it all. We try to hit the highlights with our insights on what we think differentiate the programs and what makes them good. It is up to dotTechies, who collectively have more intimate knowledge about programs than us, to supplement our reviews with feedback in the comments, like many of you have. And for that I thank you — please keep it coming!
@Ashraf: Ashraf, thanks for the update; I admit I was giving you a hard time about it all, but you take it well! What about a “poll” approach to go along with the commentaries? After a certain amount of commentaries have been provided, you could make a poll where the details can be rated, yielding a better voted outcome – along with the separated ratings for each feature. That method might yield more useful results too, by which users can choose which application they prefer.
By the way, FreeCommander has the preview option natively, without any plugins. The plugins just enhance the option.
It is my pleasure to contribute here.
Hm… just check these awards for FreeCommander – and that’s for old version from 2009, XE version is much better and it’s stable enough, even for normal users.
http://www.freecommander.com/fc_links_en.htm
@Ashraf: Fair enough. There are good reasons not to bother with betas in general. Suffice it to say that if FreeCommander XE is only a “preview” now, the standard of comparison will be higher once it is ready for full release.
For me FreeCommander XE is the best!
SpeedCommander 11 is still free and I heard a rumor that the serial works for the 64-bit version. :)
http://asset2.stern.de/media/flash/politik/kongresswahl/adventskalender_2010/sc11_stern.exe
I’ve used Xplorer2 for several years now, but it has developed a major flaw that has sent me here looking for a replacement. On my (new) high def monitor, Xplorer2 can’t keep track of the main window font setting.
It constantly nearly doubles the font size (from an 8 to a 14 point size font). This renders the program virtually useless – I never know what font size will open when I start or wind my way through the program. Its become a deal breaker for me.
Anybody else have or notice a similar problem on high def settings in any of the other programs in the list?
[@BearPup] What version of Windows are you running? I’m still using Vista Home Premium 32-bit, and Xplorer2-lite works great on my system – with an HD monitor (Dell 2407WFP-HC). I have an Nvidia GeForce GTX 550 Ti graphics card. Been using Xplorer2-lite for about 2 years now and love it. I tried over 30 file managers and this fit my needs the best). I hope to be able to pay for the full version soon….
[@Mr.Dave] I’m running Windows 7, SP1, 64 Bit version, with an ATI Radeon 5570 graphics card. The monitor is a new LG IPS224T.
When I contacted support I was told it was because I was, “using a large DPI setting for [my] desktop which has bugs for programs like xplorer2″ and likely causing errors. My DPI setting is set @ 150%. And since I can’t see the writing at 100%, its not a theory I can realistically test. Why that should make a difference I don’t know, but that was the explanation.
MS should be shot for offering that setting.
Set it back to what it should be 100%
. . .
What it does, is offer to enlarge the text displayed in the controls (EG Textbox) on a Form, but not enlarge the Form nor graphics on the Form.
I was an analyst for 20 years, and it appalls me that MS offers that setting.
Mind you I have a feeling that MS only hires programmers, and not Analysts. EG -
- The Ribbon
- The removal of classic Start Menu
- I could list more, but I won’t
PS BearPup,
Regarding your problem, of not being able to read the text -
If I could quote from the documentary ‘JAWS’ -
“You are going to need a bigger boat”
A 22″ wide screen monitor only has the vertical height of the old 4:3 19″
If you are not prepared to get a bigger monitor, try using a lower resolution.
Also there is a brilliant screen magnifier program that I use.
I press the Scroll Lock key and my whole screen is double the magnification.
Press Scroll Lock again to return to normal.
http://workerscollection.com/wcollect/english/html/mg_pro.html
DPI Problem Solved: For those of us that need to use a large DPI setting (my visual impairment requires that I use a DPI setting of 150%), the issue of font sizing has been solved! It was suggested to me by Nikos (Xplorer2 Author) that an undocumented compatibility setting was the answer; testing has borne this out.
The Solution: right-click on a program’s desktop icon and select Properties, then select the Compatibility tab. Once there, do the following:
1) Check the Run in program compatibility mode box, and from its drop-down menu select Windows 7.
2) Check the box in front of the line that reads Disable display scaling on high DPI settings.
3) Check the box in front of the line that reads Run as an administrator.
4) Click “Apply” (on the bottom row of buttons).
5) Click Apply to all users box.
6) repeat these same settings for all Users.
7) Click “Apply” (on the bottom row of buttons).
8) Click “OK” & “OK”.
I have successfully used this technique in Thunderbird (email program), my 3rd-party file manager (Xplorer2) and Firefox in order to maintain the font size I set in them.
Unfortunately, you have to do this individually for each mis-behaving application, and the settings don’t always hold, but its the best, and to date only, work-around I’ve found to the problem.