Apple steals clock design from Swiss Federal Railway, adds it to the iPad on iOS 6 without proper licensingSeptember 20, 2012 11 Email article | Print article
Apple is very outspoken about how it feels “stealing is wrong”, especially when it comes to “iconic” designs. So what happens when Apple itself does the stealing? (I propose a lightning bolt striking Cupertino but that ain’t gunna happen anytime soon.)
According to Tages Anzeiger, a Swiss newspaper, the clock design for the new iOS 6 Clock app on the iPad is blatantly a copy of the iconic clocks featured in all Switzerland trains and train stations. Of course one can argue copying is the highest form of flattery; as ArsTechnica puts it, Apple may be paying homage to the famous clock design by using it in their operating system. The only problem is the Swiss Federal Railway, also known as SBB, has a trademark on the clock design — and Apple did not properly license the trademark before copying it.
The following is a statement by Christian Ginsig, spokesperson for SBB:
We enjoy the fact that the Swiss railway clock is being used by Apple. It once again proves that it’s a real piece of design. This act, however, is an unauthorized use [of the clock's design] by Apple.
Ginsig also mentions that SBB has contacted Apple regarding the matter and are looking for a solution that respects SBB’s trademark and sees money exchanging hands. I believe a $257 per device royalty is in order here.